Start free trial Log in

Sleep and Learning: The Change That Costs Nothing

Our position: protect a child's sleep before anything else is added to their day. Start with the hour before bed. Use dimmer, warmer light. Keep devices out of the bedroom overnight. Keep the same wind-down at the same time. We hold no measurement of what that does for reading or math.

TL;DR

  1. Our position: protect a child's sleep before anything else is added to their day. A tired child is harder to start and harder to keep going. Protecting sleep is often the first thing worth changing. How much of a focus difficulty it accounts for is not something we have measured.
  2. The light studies we hold are narrower than the question. They measured evening light, mostly in adolescents. Evening light suppressed the body's signal that sleep is due. The longer the exposure, the more the light suppressed that signal.
  3. Start with the hour before bed. Use dimmer, warmer light. Keep devices out of the bedroom overnight. Keep the same wind-down at the same time each night. None of it costs anything.
  4. None of those studies measured reading, math, handwriting, memory or school attainment. The step from "sleep later" to "a worse school day" is an inference we have not tested.
  5. Some sleep problems are medical questions for a pediatrician. Trouble falling or staying asleep that keeps going. Loud snoring, or a pause in breathing. Severe sleepiness in the day. A sleep problem that a settled routine does not shift.
“

Sleep and learning is the question of what a child's sleep does to their school day. What we hold is narrower than the question. We hold evidence about evening light and when sleep starts. We hold a few studies of sleep and attention too. We also hold what we see in children who are short of sleep. We hold no measurement of what sleep does to reading, math or memory. So we protect sleep first.

”Sleep and learning

Why it comes first

Our position is that sleep is worth protecting before anything else is added to a child's day. Sleep is also one of the first things we check before deciding a child cannot focus.

The reason is ordinary. A tired child is harder to start and harder to keep going. Protecting sleep is often the first thing worth changing. It is worth changing for its own sake. How much of a focus difficulty it accounts for is not something we have measured.

The other reason is that it is free. Protecting the hour before bed costs nothing. It needs no app and no special material. It is a change to what a family does between dinner and lights out. That is all it is.

We hold no measurement of what protecting sleep does to a child's reading, math or memory.

What a child short of sleep looks like

What we see is a child who is harder to start and harder to keep going. We also see a child who is slower to recover when something goes wrong.

Short sleep often does not look like sleepiness in a child. It looks like a bad morning. It looks like a quick temper, or a task dropped at the first snag.

That changes how a morning gets read. A child who is flat in the first hour of school can look inattentive, unmotivated or difficult. The sleep behind it cannot be seen from the classroom. Our position is that sleep is worth checking before any of those words is used. We hold no measurement of how often short sleep is the explanation.

What the studies measured: evening light and when sleep starts

The studies below are about light late in the evening. They are also about when the body's signal that sleep is due arrives.

Light in the evening suppresses melatonin. Melatonin is the hormone that signals sleep is due. In particular, the short-wavelength "blue" light that screens give off suppresses it. Each study below measured how much evening light suppressed melatonin. Each one found that it did.

These are a few lab studies. Each is one study. None measured anything about school.

Figueiro and Overington (2016) studied twenty adolescents in the evening. They used self-luminous devices, meaning screens that give off their own light. Melatonin suppression grew the longer they used the devices.

Nagare, Plitnick and Figueiro (2019) found the same direction across a wider range of exposure lengths. The same study compared adolescents with adults directly. The age difference it found was about the color of the light. It was not about light in general. The adolescents were more affected by cooler, bluer light than by warmer light. The adults showed no difference between the two. That is one small study and one lighting comparison. It supports "cooler light is the worse choice late in the evening." It does not support "a child's system is generally more fragile than a parent's."

Crowley and colleagues (2015) compared younger and older adolescents in the evening. The younger group was more affected at every light level tested. The lowest level tested was a dim bedside lamp, not a screen. A separate morning-light part of the same study found no difference between the groups.

What none of it shows is the part a parent wants. Not one of these studies measured reading, math, handwriting, memory or school attainment. They measured melatonin. The step from "melatonin later" to "a worse school day" is an inference we have not tested. It is the reason we think protecting the evening is worth doing. It is not a demonstrated effect on learning.

The hour before bed

Here is what to change in the evening.

Dimmer and warmer light. Use lamps, not overhead lights. Choose warmer bulbs where you can. Only one study we hold compared cooler light with warmer light. In that study, cooler, bluer light was the worse choice late in the evening.

Devices out of the bedroom overnight. Charge them somewhere else. Turn screens off a half hour to an hour before bed. The light matters, and so does what is on the screen. In our experience, a fast game or a feed right before bed winds a child up. The wind-up adds to what the light does.

The same wind-down at the same time. Keep the same order each night: bath, book, bed, or your family's own version. Do it at a time that does not move much between school nights. Consistent sleep and wake times are worth keeping for their own sake.

This advice rests on the evidence about light and timing. It does not depend on any claim about school results.

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) gives screen advice for children six and older. It does not set a fixed number of screen hours. It asks each family to set consistent limits of its own. Those limits should protect sleep, physical activity, school, meals and time with people. For children six and older, the AAP names 8 to 12 hours of sleep, depending on age.

Whether screens moved school results is a separate question with a separate answer. We do not run the two questions together.

What we do not hold

We hold no table of sleep hours by age. The AAP's range above is one range, not a table. We hold no full set of sleep rules beyond the hour before bed. This page does not cover diagnosed sleep disorders, or managing one.

We hold no measurement of what sleep does to reading, math, handwriting or memory. Nor do we hold one for school performance. We have neither run nor found such a measurement. That is a gap in what we hold. The gap is not a finding that the effect is small.

So we treat sleep here the way we treat it with families. We protect it first. We hold no measure of what it does to school results.

How to talk about it

In our view, "you're a poor sleeper" gives a child a label for who they are. "We're learning to settle at night" gives them something to practice.

So describe the habit, not the child. Say "We are working on winding down," not "You never sleep." And keep the morning apart from the night. A bad morning after a short night tells you about the evening before. Tell your child the same thing. Do not let the morning become a verdict on them.

When it is somebody else's question

Some sleep problems are not about the evening routine. This page is not built for them:

Those are medical questions, and they go to a pediatrician. This is the one route on this page we cannot walk with you. It is a medical route, and it is worth asking for.

In the classroom

1

Some children are flat in the first period and fine after lunch. A child like that may be short of sleep, not short of interest. Notice which hour the trouble shows up in. Do that before reading it as attitude.

2

Where you can, put the work that takes the most effort to start after the first hour. Or make the first task of the day a short one the child can finish.

3

Tell the family what you see as something you noticed, not as advice about bedtime. Parents hear "she seems very tired in the mornings" differently from "she needs more sleep."

4

One sentence for an email home: "I have noticed that he finds the first hour hard to get going in. He is much more himself by mid-morning. I am going to start his day with a short task he can finish. I wanted you to know what I am seeing."

What to use next

free

Focus Foundations

A free PDF for parents of children who are building focus.

free

Free Resources

Downloads and free programs, if you are not sure yet what you need.

membership

All Access

Every Learning Success program in one membership.

Key Takeaways

1

Our position: protect a child's sleep before anything else is added to their day. It is worth protecting for its own sake. How much of a focus difficulty it accounts for is not something we have measured.

2

A child short of sleep is harder to start and harder to keep going. We also see them slower to recover from a setback. Short sleep often looks like a bad morning, not sleepiness.

3

The light studies we hold measured evening light and when sleep starts. They studied adolescents and a small group of adults. None of them measured reading, math, memory or school attainment.

4

Start with the hour before bed. Use dimmer, warmer light. Keep devices out of the bedroom overnight. Keep the same wind-down at the same time. It costs nothing.

5

Some sleep problems are medical questions for a pediatrician. Trouble falling or staying asleep that keeps going. Loud snoring, or pauses in breathing. Severe sleepiness in the day.

“

Tonight, use lamps instead of the overhead light for the last hour. Charge every screen outside the bedroom. Change nothing else. Notice whether tomorrow's first hour looks different. Notice it again the morning after.

”What to do tonight

Common questions from parents

How much sleep does my child need?

Ask your pediatrician about your own child. For children six and older, the American Academy of Pediatrics names 8 to 12 hours, depending on age. It says this in its advice on screen limits. That is one range, not a table by age, and we hold no such table. Protect the hour before bed. Keep the wake-up time steady on school nights. Is your child flat in the first hour and fine by mid-morning? Read that as a question about the evening before.

Will more sleep improve my child's grades?

We hold no measurement of that. The light studies we hold measured evening light. They found it suppresses the signal that sleep is due. What we see is that a tired child is harder to start and harder to keep going. Protect sleep for what it does for the child.

Is it really the screen, or is it just late bedtimes?

The light matters, and in our view so does the hour. At home they are hard to separate. The screen studies we hold measured the light. One used self-luminous devices, meaning screens that give off their own light. In that study, evening screen light suppressed the signal that sleep is due. Longer exposure suppressed it more. What was on the screen was not what it measured. Either way, the answer is the same: screens off before bed, and out of the bedroom overnight.

We have a settled routine and she still cannot fall asleep. What now?

That is a question for a pediatrician. A sleep problem that does not shift with a settled evening routine is a medical question. So are loud snoring, pauses in breathing and severe sleepiness in the day. This page is not built to answer them. Take what you have already tried, and for how long, to the appointment.

Start Building Real Skills Today

One membership, every program, no upgrade path.

All Access includes every Learning Success program. You're never one more purchase away from the thing your child needs.