Start free trial Log in

Executive Function in Plain English

As we describe it, executive function is a set of ordinary jobs. They get work started and keep it on track. We name five: starting, keeping track of things, judging time, switching plans, and noticing how it is going. Our position is that each is a skill built by practice. In our view, none of them is a fixed limit.

TL;DR

  1. Executive function, as we describe it, is a handful of ordinary jobs with a clinical-sounding name. We name five: starting, keeping track, judging time, switching plans, and noticing how it is going.
  2. A child can be solid at one job and stuck on another. We ask which job is not built yet, not whether a child "has" executive function.
  3. Our position: each job is a skill built by practice, with support in place while it is built. In our view, none of them is a fixed limit.
  4. Practice reaches the thing it is practice at. Practicing the real homework with a checklist builds checklist-and-homework. A memory game played instead has not been shown to reach the reading or the math.
  5. We hold no measurement of what this page's strategies do to executive function or school results.
“

As we describe it, executive function is a set of everyday jobs. They get work started and keep it on track. The first three are starting a task, keeping track of materials and steps, and judging time. The other two are changing course when the plan changes, and noticing how it is going. Working memory means holding something in mind while using it. It is a separate job these lean on. In our view, executive function is a set of skills a child builds, not an amount.

”Executive function

What the term means, in plain words

The phrase often arrives on a report card or from a teacher. It can sound like a diagnosis. It is not one. It is an umbrella word for a handful of everyday jobs.

Some children know what to do and cannot start. Some lose track of their things. Some have no sense of how long a task takes. Some get very upset when the plan changes. Each of those is one job under the umbrella. Executive function, as we describe it, is the whole set of jobs under that umbrella.

To us, the word is a list, not a verdict. A child can be strong at one of these jobs and stuck on another. The practice is different for each. So we do not ask whether a child "has" executive function. We ask which job is not built yet.

The jobs, one at a time

Here are the jobs, each with what it looks like at the kitchen table. Our position: each one is a skill built by practice, with support in place while it is built.

Getting started. Knowing what the work is and not being able to begin. A report may call it task initiation. It is different from not being able to keep going once started. It is not always refusal, though from the doorway the two look alike. We also list starting among the attention jobs. The two lists overlap.

Keeping track of things. Materials, steps, due dates, where the worksheet went. A report may call this planning and organization. A child who loses the sheet is showing you one difficulty. A child who cannot stay with the sheet once found is showing you another.

Judging time. Knowing how long something will take, how much time has gone, and when to stop. To us, a child with no working sense of time is not being careless about it. Our position: judging time is a skill like the others, built by estimating and checking.

Switching when the plan changes. Moving from one task to the next. Or changing how you do something when the first way is not working. A report may call this cognitive flexibility.

Noticing how it is going. Checking the work against what was asked. Catching a wrong turn before the end. Knowing when to ask for help. A report may call this self-monitoring. In our view, it is the job that lets the other four correct themselves.

Stopping the first impulse sits next to these jobs. That means waiting before answering, or leaving the interesting thing in the corner alone. It overlaps with attention. We treat the two as neighbors, not as the same thing.

You will also meet working memory under this heading. It means holding something in mind while you use it. Following a two-part instruction is one example. Keeping a number in your head while you work with it is another. So is remembering the start of your own sentence. A child who loses a two-part instruction may follow a one-part instruction perfectly. Working memory is one of the jobs running at once. It is not the single thing that explains the rest.

What it is not

In our view, it is not a statement about how bright a child is. A child can understand the work completely. The same child can still be unable to start, organize or finish it. A child can be smart and still struggle. To us, that gap between knowing and doing is where these jobs sit.

We do not see it as a fixed limit. Our position is that these are abilities built through practice and support, not fixed limits. Compare two things a child might hear. One is "keeping track of things is a skill you are practicing." The other is "you are disorganized." To us, only the first gives a child something to work on.

Where the practice happens

The strategies are familiar. What is worth noticing is where they are practiced. In our view, that decides whether the practice reaches the thing you care about.

Break the work into pieces a child can see the end of. Four problems, not twenty. One paragraph, not the page.

Use a checklist the child checks off, not one you hold. Have the child write the steps, one at a time, where possible. Keeping track of things is practiced by keeping track of things.

Estimate the time before the timer starts. Ask, "How long do you think this will take?" Then set a timer, and compare.

Say the change before it happens. "In five minutes we are stopping this and starting that." That is still practice at switching.

Ask what was asked. Before work is handed in, ask: "What did the question want?" Noticing how it went is practiced by looking back.

Write instructions down as well as saying them. Ask for a printed copy instead of copying from the board. Give one step at a time. None of that is cheating. Our position is that reducing the load does not stop the skill being built.

Do every one of these on the real work: the homework, the reading, the math. A child who practices a checklist on the homework gets better at checklists on homework. A child who plays a puzzle app instead of the homework gets better at the app.

What has been tested, and what the evidence says

This part of the market is sold on a promise. The promise is that a general exercise will show up later as better schoolwork. It might be a memory game or a speed drill. Or it might be a program that trains "executive function" as a general power.

Melby-LervÄg, Redick and Hulme (2016) pooled the working-memory training studies. Their review covered 87 publications and 145 comparisons. They found that people got better at working-memory tasks. Against a treated control, they found no convincing carry-over to verbal ability, word reading, reading comprehension or arithmetic. Trained scores go up. The gains have repeatedly failed to reach the academic skills people bought the training for. Researchers still argue about whether some limited carry-over happens. So it is still an open question.

Simons and colleagues (2016) reviewed the wider set of programs. They found the same shape. They found good evidence for the trained task, less for closely related tasks, and little for distant ones.

Kassai and colleagues (2019) pooled the studies that trained executive function in children. They found the same again. Children got better at tasks close to the training. Carry-over to the untrained executive-function jobs did not reach significance. That paper did not measure schoolwork. If a program promises a memory drill will improve homework, check that claim.

Several studies we hold measured executive function as an outcome. One was a martial-arts trial, not a checklist. Ng-Knight and colleagues (2022; online 2021) randomized children one by one. The assessors did not know which group a child was in. Attention improved, and conduct problems fell. The trial found no improvement in response inhibition, working memory, task switching or impulsivity. What carried the gain in teacher-rated attention was the children coming to value the activity. It was not a gain in executive function. That finding is about a program the children came to value. It is not evidence that the strategies on this page change executive function.

We hold no measurement of what this page's strategies do to executive function or school results. Again and again, we see children who practice starting small pieces get better at starting them. We also see that the pieces can grow. That is a claim about the skill being practiced.

Before you decide it is executive function

This is the first question, not the last one. Our position is that a word like "disorganized" has to be earned before it is used. In our experience, once it is used, what a child does next gets read through it.

A school skill that is still hard. When reading, writing or math is still hard work, less is left for planning and starting. A child who cannot yet read the worksheet easily can look unable to organize it. Our position is that this is worth checking first. We hold no measurement of how often it is the explanation.

Short or broken sleep. A tired child is harder to start and harder to keep going. Protecting sleep is often the first thing worth changing. It is worth changing for its own sake. How much of the difficulty it accounts for is not something we have measured.

Worry about the work, not an inability to organize it. A child avoiding the page can look like a child who cannot start it. From across a room, the two look the same. They need opposite responses. We hold no study of how to tell them apart.

Hearing or vision that has not been checked recently. This is the one route on this list we cannot walk with you. A check is a medical route, and it is worth asking for.

We hold no measurement of how often any of these is the explanation. Nothing on this page tells them apart. Nothing on this page rules anything in or out.

In the classroom

1

A child who cannot begin is not always refusing. Name the first physical action, not the task: "write today's date," not "start your work."

2

A child who loses a two-part instruction may follow a one-part instruction perfectly. Written steps let the child check rather than remember.

3

Announce a switch before it happens. "Two more minutes, then we move to reading" is practice at switching.

4

One sentence for an email home: "He understands the work. He has a hard time getting started and keeping the pieces in order. So I am giving him written steps and a smaller first piece. I wanted you to know what I am seeing."

Key Takeaways

1

As we describe it, executive function is a set of ordinary jobs. In our view, it is not an amount a child has. We name five: starting, keeping track, judging time, switching plans, and noticing how it is going. Ask which job is not built yet.

2

Our position: each job is a skill built by practice, with support in place while it is built.

3

Practice reaches the thing it is practice at. A checklist used on the homework builds checklist-and-homework. A memory game played instead has not been shown to reach the reading or the math.

4

We hold no measurement of what this page's strategies do to executive function or school results.

5

Before deciding it is executive function, look at a school skill that is still hard. Look at sleep, at worry about the work, and at hearing and vision too.

“

Take one thing your child has to do tomorrow morning. Write it as three steps on a sticky note, in their words. Put a box beside each. Hand it over and say nothing else. Notice whether the boxes get checked.

”What to do tonight

What to use next

free

Focus Foundations

A free PDF for parents of children who are building focus.

free

Free Resources

Downloads and free programs, if you are not sure yet what you need.

membership

All Access

Every Learning Success program in one membership.

Common questions from parents

What are executive function skills, in a list?

As we describe them, there are five. The first three are getting started, keeping track of materials and steps, and judging time. The other two are switching when the plan changes, and noticing how the work is going. Stopping the first impulse sits next to these and overlaps with attention. Working memory is holding something in mind while using it. It is a separate job the others lean on. That is our list.

Is executive function the same as attention?

They overlap, but we see them as different. To us, keeping track of materials and judging how long something takes are organizing jobs. Getting started sits on both lists. Staying with a task once started is one of the attention jobs. One child cannot find the worksheet. Another finds it and cannot stay with it. The practice is different for each.

Can executive function be taught?

Our position: each job is a skill built by practice, with support in place while it is built. In our view, the practice that reaches the homework is practice on the homework. That means smaller pieces, written steps, and a timer the child checks. We hold no measurement of what those strategies do to executive function or school results.

Does executive function mean my child has ADHD?

No. It is an umbrella word for a set of jobs. Every child is somewhere on each of them. Nothing on this page rules anything in or out, and we are not able to. This page helps you see which job is worth practicing. That way you are not waiting on a name before you start.

Start Building Real Skills Today

One membership, every program, no upgrade path.

All Access includes every Learning Success program. You're never one more purchase away from the thing your child needs.